The Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) Study: A Lens on Trauma in the Deaf and Coda Communities

Adverse Childhood Experiences (ACEs) have been a cornerstone in understanding how early life trauma impacts health and well-being. The landmark ACE study, conducted by the CDC and Kaiser Permanente in the 1990s, surveyed over 17,000 participants to explore the long-term effects of childhood trauma. The findings were groundbreaking, revealing that the more ACEs an individual experienced, the higher their risk for chronic health conditions, mental illness, substance abuse, and even early death.

In this post, we’ll delve into the ACE study, its findings, and its profound implications for the Deaf and Coda (Children of Deaf Adults) communities, where unique layers of trauma often exist.

---

What is the ACE Study?

The ACE study measures exposure to 10 specific types of childhood trauma divided into three categories:

1. Abuse:
   • Physical
   • Emotional
   • Sexual
2. Neglect:
   • Physical
   • Emotional
3. Household Dysfunction:
   • Parental separation or divorce
   • Domestic violence
   • Substance abuse
   • Mental illness
   • Incarceration of a household member

Participants score 1 point for each type of trauma they experienced. A higher ACE score is linked to greater health risks, including:

• Heart disease
• Depression
• Obesity
• Substance use disorders
• Suicide attempts

The study’s most compelling takeaway is the dose-response relationship: as ACE scores increase, so does the likelihood of adverse outcomes.

---

Unique Trauma in the Deaf and Coda Communities

The Deaf and Coda communities often experience unique challenges that align with or extend beyond the ACE framework. Language barriers, cultural isolation, and systemic inaccessibility can exacerbate trauma. Let’s explore how ACEs manifest in these communities.

Deaf Individuals

1. Language Deprivation:
   Many Deaf individuals grow up without full access to language, particularly if their families do not use sign language. Language deprivation is a form of emotional neglect with profound cognitive, emotional, and social consequences.
2. Cultural Isolation:
   Deaf children born into hearing families often feel isolated due to communication barriers and lack of cultural connection. This isolation can lead to feelings of neglect and unimportance.
3. Systemic Barriers:
   Limited access to mental health services, interpreters, and education can further compound the challenges Deaf individuals face, perpetuating cycles of neglect and trauma.

Codas

1. Parentification:
   Many Codas take on adult responsibilities at a young age, interpreting for their Deaf parents in complex situations such as medical appointments or legal matters. This role reversal can lead to emotional stress and feelings of inadequacy.
2. Cultural Dissonance:
   Codas often navigate two worlds—the Deaf world and the hearing world. Straddling these identities can cause confusion, isolation, and a sense of not fully belonging to either community.
3. Intergenerational Trauma:
   Codas may inherit the trauma experienced by their Deaf parents, such as discrimination, economic hardship, or language deprivation. This legacy burden can impact their mental health and relationships.

---

Expanding the ACE Framework for the Deaf and Coda Communities

The ACE study provides a foundation, but adaptations are necessary to capture the unique experiences of the Deaf and Coda communities. Additional questions could address:

1. Language Deprivation:
   Did you grow up without access to a language you fully understood, such as ASL?
2. Social Isolation:
   Did you feel excluded in family or school activities because no one communicated with you in a way you understood?
3. Parentification (for Codas):
   Did you have to take on adult responsibilities, such as interpreting, at a young age?
4. Forced Oralism (for Deaf individuals):
   Were you discouraged or prevented from using sign language, making it hard to express yourself?

---

The Impact of ACEs in the Deaf and Coda Communities

The trauma associated with high ACE scores is magnified in communities already marginalized by systemic barriers. For Deaf individuals, untreated trauma can lead to increased risks of mental health disorders, unemployment, and substance abuse. For Codas, the dual role of navigating Deaf and hearing cultures can result in anxiety, depression, and strained familial relationships.

By understanding how ACEs intersect with Deaf and Coda experiences, we can better tailor trauma-informed care, ensuring that individuals in these communities have access to the resources they need to heal.

---

Breaking the Cycle: Toward Trauma-Informed Support

1. For Deaf Individuals:
   • Expand access to mental health services with qualified therapists fluent in ASL.
   • Address language deprivation as a critical issue in childhood development.
2. For Codas:
   • Provide support groups where Codas can share their experiences and connect with peers.
   • Recognize parentification and its long-term impact, offering counseling and resources for healing.
3. For Both Communities:
   • Advocate for inclusive policies that address systemic inequities, such as accessible education and healthcare.
   • Promote research to explore the intersection of ACEs and Deaf/Coda experiences, filling gaps in existing studies.

---

Conclusion

The ACE study has illuminated how childhood trauma shapes lives, offering a pathway for understanding and intervention. In the Deaf and Coda communities, adapting this framework is essential to acknowledge the unique adversities they face. By expanding our lens and adopting trauma-informed approaches, we can break cycles of trauma and create environments where Deaf individuals and Codas can thrive.

Let’s continue the conversation, advocating for inclusion, accessibility, and healing for all.

Take the ACE modified for Codas here…

Take the ACE modified for Deaf here…

To learn more about the ACE study and explore the original questionnaire, visit CDC’s ACE Study Resource Page.